City Cast Boise logo

The Not-So-Romantic Origins of Valentine’s Day

Posted on February 8, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Natalia Aldana

Natalia Aldana

An engraving of the martyred St. Valentine by an Italian artist in 1886. (Fototeca Storica Nazionale/Getty Images)

An engraving of the martyred St. Valentine by an Italian artist in 1886. (Fototeca Storica Nazionale/Getty Images)

City Cast

Date Nights for Valentine’s Day and Beyond

00:00:00

Valentine’s Day is a holiday filled with romance, love, and of course the commercialization of our appreciation for the special people in our lives. But the origins of this romantic holiday actually range from pretty dark to downright strange, depending on which folklore you believe.

Beheaded in the Name of Love

The Catholic Church recognizes several versions of a martyred St. Valentine. One story is that a priest by the name of Valentine, or Valentinus, married couples in secret after Roman Emperor Claudius II outlawed marriage for young men, thinking it would make them better soldiers. Another story is that an imprisoned Bishop Valentine of Tern sent a love note to his beloved and signed it, “From your Valentine.” All stories of the patron saints of lovers end with them being beheaded.

How Animal Blood Led to Marriage

Why do we celebrate on Feb. 14? Many credit the ancient pagan Roman festival of Lupercalia, which took place in mid-February. During this celebration of fertility, priests “gently” slapped women with goat hides dipped in blood, believing it would make them more fertile (which just sounds messy, right?). The party would end with young men drawing women’s names from jars, and they would be coupled up for the festival, which ideally would lead to their marriage.

From its Dark Origins to Modern-Day Interpretations

As the Romans departed from paganism, it’s believed the Catholic Church replaced this sexy celebration with St. Valentine’s Day. Another folklore is that the Norman people’s celebration of Galatin’s Day, the “lover of women,” (Galentine’s Day, anyone?!) was eventually combined with Valentine’s Day because of how similar they were pronounced. William Shakespeare and other writers are credited with romanticizing the holiday and creating mass appeal. At the turn of the 20th century, Hallmark Cards in Kansas City, Missouri began mass-producing Valentine’s Day cards.

Now that you know the dark origins of Valentine’s Day, does this day still inspire romance for you? Love is patient, love is kind, but never forget it can also be weird and dramatic. Happy Valentine’s Day!

Share article

Hey Boise

Thank you Boise, we’ve loved the conversation we’ve been having with you for the past three years. City Cast Boise and Hey Boise have suspended operations. Our last newsletter and podcast episode was Oct. 24, 2025.

Boise, Explained

See All
Boise, ExplainedOctober 6, 2025

Unemployment Remains Low, But Housing Affordability Stays Out of Reach

All year, much of the U.S. has braced for an economic recession, wary of tariffs, federal layoffs, and general cost-of-living. But when i...

Some Boise job markets are booming — but even in the hottest industries, pay still trails behind housing affordability. (simonkr / Getty)
Boise, ExplainedOctober 3, 2025

How Well Do You Know Idaho's Geological History?

I’m feeling a little bogged down by the news, and sometimes it’s helpful to combat that by looking into the history books.

What are a large swath of Idaho’s mountains made of? (David Radzieta / Getty)
Boise, ExplainedSeptember 19, 2025

Quiz: How Well Do You Know Boise's Parks By Sight?

I kept these largely limited to Boise’s most popular parks, so see if you can place them.

Which park do you think this is? (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)
Boise, ExplainedSeptember 11, 2025

What Would It Take? Dreaming of Commuter Rail in the Treasure Valley.

A Compass study found that the Boise Cutoff rail is immensely popular, but it would require an additional track to be laid and bridges to...

Idaho missed out on an opportunity for Amtrak last year — but could a more local option bring rail passengers through the Boise Depot? (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)
Boise, ExplainedAugust 22, 2025

How Well Do You Know Boise’s Streets?

Recently, I’ve tested you on weather and climate, on public lands, and the news.

Paths connect us, but can you connect these clues about paths? (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)
Boise, ExplainedAugust 21, 2025

Challenges to Idaho's Abortion Bans Are Mostly Finished, and OB-GYNs Are Fleeing. What's Next?

Before this data analysis, Idaho already ranked among the bottom of the barrel for fewest OB-GYNs per capita of any state.

Idaho’s EMTALA case, along with most of the challenges against Idaho’s abortion bans, is over. What’s next? (Idaho Statesman / Getty)
Boise, ExplainedAugust 18, 2025

What the New Anti-Camping Law Means for Boise

Police and housing advocates agree: The state’s punishment for public camping actually hurt the public's ability to help unhoused people.

Police and housing advocates agree: The state’s punishment for public camping actually hamstrung the ability to help unhoused people. (mikexavier / Getty)
Boise, ExplainedAugust 8, 2025

How Well Do You Know Your Meteorology?

To celebrate the benevolent weather and mostly smoke-free air, today’s quiz is all atmosphere!

Precipitation moves in from the ocean, but what’s it called when the mountains catch the moisture and dry the air? (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)

The latest in Boise

AnnouncementsOctober 24, 2025

Goodbye from City Cast Boise and Hey Boise

City Cast Boise and Hey Boise have suspended operations.

illustration of skyline with the capitol building, trees, and hot air balloons with "we heart boise"
Boise's BestOctober 21, 2025

Essential Rules for Surviving Boise

In Boise, you need good footwear, a curiosity for breweries, and political resilience. Here are some of the essential rules for surviving...

Cheers to thriving in Boise — or getting closer to it! (Nicolas Micolani / Getty)
Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Jimmy Hallyburton, District 6, Incumbent

Hallyburton faces perhaps the most challenging path to reelection, with former City Council member Lisa Sánchez running to unseat him, an...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Lisa E. Sánchez, District 6, Challenger

Sánchez’s return to city hall would be remarkable, as her exit was marked with contention and a lawsuit. But that’s in the past: Her resu...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Josh Ellstrom, District 2, Challenger

Ellstrom is a home physical therapist and political newcomer with his eye trained on political neutrality. He’s challenging West Bench in...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

How Boise City Council Candidates Set Themselves Apart

Three council seats are up for election on Nov. 4. Early voting starts today, so here's what Boiseans need to know for the city council e...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Colin Nash, District 2, Incumbent

Colin Nash is an incumbent but this is his first time seeking a council seat at the ballot box. In 2023, he was appointed to fill a seat...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Jordan Morales, District 4, Incumbent

Morales is unchallenged in his bid for a second term representing District 4 and East Boise. Luckily, he was still kind enough to fill ou...