City Cast Boise logo

Local Civics: Early Foundations in the Mayoral Race

Posted on May 30, 2023   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Blake Hunter

Blake Hunter

After ten years as the BPD chief and seven years of retirement, Mike Masterson is trying to make it back to city hall. (Mike Masterson for Boise Mayor / Facebook)

After ten years as the BPD chief and seven years of retirement, Mike Masterson is trying to make it back to city hall. (Mike Masterson for Boise Mayor / Facebook)

Welcome to the local politics corner! I don’t want to go too deep into city elections yet, but here’s a snapshot of what’s played out in the mayoral race in the last couple weeks. We’ll have explainers on the city council races soon.

After ten years as the BPD chief and seven years of retirement, Mike Masterson is trying to make it back to city hall. (Mike Masterson for Boise Mayor / Facebook)

After ten years as the BPD chief and seven years of retirement, Mike Masterson is trying to make it back to city hall. (Mike Masterson for Boise Mayor / Facebook)

Masterson gets his feet set for the running.

  • Like I said recently on City Cast Boise, the rhetoric of public safety and policing will be crucial in the mayoral election. Former Boise Police Department (BPD) chief Mike Masterson is already putting a lot of eggs in this basket as he challenges Mayor Lauren McLean, hoping to direct as much blame for BPD’s recent controversies on her.
  • Running as an independent, Masterson is certainly to McLean’s right, but we’re still waiting to see what ideological lane he sticks with. His support from former Democratic legislator Maryanne Jordan and former mayor David Bieter should help his chances with moderate Democrats.
  • Apart from decrying high housing costs and low supply, Masterson’s housing platform still seems to be in the works. He’s said that the zoning code rewrite goes too far and that he wants to see more development, but we’ll likely hear more on this soon.
McLean defeated a long-time mayor in a run-off in 2019, and has some harsh critics in her first election as an incumbent. (McLean for Boise)

McLean defeated a long-time mayor in a run-off in 2019, and has some harsh critics in her first election as an incumbent. (McLean for Boise)

Can McLean’s campaign get control of the narrative?

  • I don’t know if Mayor Lauren McLean will try to employ the “we don’t want to become Portland” approach again, but it is certainly being used against her, which we’ll see a lot more of through the race.
  • That’s partially because of a decade-long project: the zoning code rewrite. City council is slated to vote on that in a couple weeks, and it’s a big part of what McLean will probably hang her hat on.
  • McLean’s up against a former BPD chief, but she’s still trying to stake her claim on the public safety front, as we saw in her State of the City address. There are a lot of people, however, who don’t accept her current explanations for the controversies within BPD.

Share article

Hey Boise

Thank you Boise, we’ve loved the conversation we’ve been having with you for the past three years. City Cast Boise and Hey Boise have suspended operations. Our last newsletter and podcast episode was Oct. 24, 2025.

Local Civics

See All
Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Jimmy Hallyburton, District 6, Incumbent

Hallyburton faces perhaps the most challenging path to reelection, with former City Council member Lisa Sánchez running to unseat him, an...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Lisa E. Sánchez, District 6, Challenger

Sánchez’s return to city hall would be remarkable, as her exit was marked with contention and a lawsuit. But that’s in the past: Her resu...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Josh Ellstrom, District 2, Challenger

Ellstrom is a home physical therapist and political newcomer with his eye trained on political neutrality. He’s challenging West Bench in...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

How Boise City Council Candidates Set Themselves Apart

Three council seats are up for election on Nov. 4. Early voting starts today, so here's what Boiseans need to know for the city council e...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Colin Nash, District 2, Incumbent

Colin Nash is an incumbent but this is his first time seeking a council seat at the ballot box. In 2023, he was appointed to fill a seat...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Jordan Morales, District 4, Incumbent

Morales is unchallenged in his bid for a second term representing District 4 and East Boise. Luckily, he was still kind enough to fill ou...

Local CivicsOctober 20, 2025

Meet the 2025 Boise City Council Candidates: Derek James Smith, District 2, Challenger

Another political newcomer, Derek Smith has new ideas for city hall. Autonomous buses? I’m listening. I’m also listening because his Benc...

Local CivicsOctober 7, 2025

Want to Get Involved? Here Are Some Ways to Volunteer.

We know Hey Boise readers are involved, and often want to be more involved.

There are many ways to chip in this fall — even just with your feedback. (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)

The latest in Boise

AnnouncementsOctober 24, 2025

Goodbye from City Cast Boise and Hey Boise

City Cast Boise and Hey Boise have suspended operations.

illustration of skyline with the capitol building, trees, and hot air balloons with "we heart boise"
Boise's BestOctober 21, 2025

Essential Rules for Surviving Boise

In Boise, you need good footwear, a curiosity for breweries, and political resilience. Here are some of the essential rules for surviving...

Cheers to thriving in Boise — or getting closer to it! (Nicolas Micolani / Getty)
Boise HistoryOctober 9, 2025

A Brief History of Colonization in the Treasure Valley (Ahead of Indigenous People's Day)

A recent outburst from North Idaho Sen. Dan Foreman shows why many Idahoans need to reckon with the state's Indigenous and colonial history.

Before Europeans arrived, this valley was a gathering place for many peoples. (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)
Boise, ExplainedOctober 6, 2025

Unemployment Remains Low, But Housing Affordability Stays Out of Reach

All year, much of the U.S. has braced for an economic recession, wary of tariffs, federal layoffs, and general cost-of-living. But when i...

Some Boise job markets are booming — but even in the hottest industries, pay still trails behind housing affordability. (simonkr / Getty)
Boise, ExplainedOctober 3, 2025

How Well Do You Know Idaho's Geological History?

I’m feeling a little bogged down by the news, and sometimes it’s helpful to combat that by looking into the history books.

What are a large swath of Idaho’s mountains made of? (David Radzieta / Getty)
Urban AlmanacOctober 2, 2025

Urban Almanac: Cat-Faced Orb Weaver Spiders

Most orb-weavers, including the cat-faced spider, are non-venomous to humans. And — as is clearly visible by their large webs — they play...

This is a type of orb-weaver similar to the cat-faced spider common in Boise. (Zigmunds Dizgalvis / Getty)
Boise's BestOctober 1, 2025

Your Guide to Boise in October 2025

Somehow it’s October, so this month, find a little balance between the busy times, Halloween, and cozy autumn vibes Boise brings.

We’re luckily having a beautiful fall, so make the most of it! (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)
Food & DrinkSeptember 26, 2025

Boise's Best New Restaurants and Bars

Here’s what’s new, and what's taken a final bow.

Slow by Slow has expanded, and changed its aesthetic. It’s worth checking out! (Blake Hunter / City Cast Boise)